Friday, May 27, 2011

Leadership = Common Purpose

As we continue our exploration of the Social Change Model (SCM) of leadership development, we move to the next group value: Common Purpose.   You have probably worked with at least one or two groups and, if so, you know that any functional group or team must have a shared vision, a common aim, and some mutual values that will determine its future, its goals, and how the members of the group treat each other and do their work.   These three factors combine to form the groups’ common purpose (Teh, 2009).

Goals and Aims
The aims or goals of a group answer the question, “What are we here to do?” and often distinguish them from similar groups.  For example, if you are a member of a disc golf team, what are its goals?  To compete hard and win?  To create teamwork and build players’ skills?  To provide entertainment and fun for team members?  (Paraphrased from Teh, 2009, p. 242).  Failure to have shared goals will prevent goal attainment and, in the above example, create much frustration among team members.  Any team, therefore, must be explicit about their goals.  (Note to anarchists:  You are the only ones with a “get out of goals free” card.  Everyone else, agree on clear ones, please.) 

Values
As noted in Teh (2009), having a common set of values will determine how the team gets the work done and how they treat team members and others in the process.  Common values help socialize new members and can act as a filter, winnowing out potential team members whose personal values are not a good fit.  So for our disc golf team noted above, if the goal is winning the most games, is it by “any means necessary”?  Or will it be accomplished by good sportsmanship and fairness?  Will all players get to play or only those who are the best at a given position?  Team members who have values different from the team’s shared values will likely not be effective.

Vision
 The purpose of a vision is to inspire group members and motivate them to success, however that’s measured in a given context  (Teh, 2009).  Vision fits with goals and values by providing a long-term end. Most, if not all, of the most successful organizations have clearly articulated vision statements. 
What’s Google’s?  “To develop a perfect search engine.”  Starbucks?  “To inspire and nurture the human spirit – one person, one cup and one neighborhood at a time.”  In the team noted above, is its vision winning the national disc golf championship?  Or is it to create a tight-knit group of long-term friends who still play together in 20 years?  Or to raise disc golf awareness in the team’s local area?   Knowing which vision you’re working toward over the long term will help set priorities and inspire performance. 

When a group forms its Common Purpose – its vision, mission and values – members should generally all have a voice in the end product (Teh, 2009).  While charismatic leaders may be able to use their personal vision to recruit group members and determine goals and values, most groups are more effective if the purpose is determined by consensus or similar methods.  This increases trust and engagement with the group purpose from team members. 

Common Purpose is the second group factor in the SCM.  It is critically important to the success of the group and to its individual members.  Without common goals, vision and values, little of value can be accomplished.   

Teh, A.  (2009).  Common purpose.  In Komives, S. R., Wagner, W. & Associates (Eds.), Leadership for a better world: Understanding the social change model of leadership development (pp. 237 – 262). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.



Monday, April 18, 2011

Leadership = Collaboration


Collaboration is the next part of the Social Change Leadership Development Model or SCM.  (For an overview of the model (and an explanation of what is meant by “social change”), please see the previous posts.)  To understand collaboration, it’s helpful to understand its opposite, competition.  Competition can have positive outcomes.  The lessons one can learn from participating in sports, for example, would be much different without it.  Research reveals that individuals, however, learn more if they collaborate than if they compete, because the former allows them to concentrate on the subject rather than having to split their focus between content and the competition.  In terms of motivation:
Competition usually does not motivate people to do the best that they can; it only motivates them to do better than the others.  It actually limits how high one’s goals are set.  It encourages a focus on beating others, rather than focusing on doing well.  Winning…may produce short-term gains, [but] a continued focus on beating others tends to erode one’s intrinsic or internal motivation to strive toward excellence on a task (Kohn, 1986, as cited in Komives, Wagner and Associates, 2009, p. 200).

The goal of collaboration is synergy, in which the whole is greater than the sum of its parts (Covey, 1989).  But how does this work? How is that synergy attained?  Through a variety of personal competencies, including doing personal work, building trust and communicating effectively.

Personal Work

Effective collaboration starts with you. “Oh no!” I hear you pragmatists saying.  “Here comes the touchy feely navel gazing!”  No navel gazing is required (unless you’re into that -- I don’t judge) but even you hardcore realists must admit that it is difficult to understand others if you don’t know what makes you tick.  So, as Mark McGrath recently advised Gary Busey on Celebrity Apprentice, “Look inward…Take a big swim in Lake You and see what you find.”  In terms of the collaboration that means increasing your awareness of your own perspectives, beliefs, styles and needs. 

Building Trust

I personally believe that the best way to have trust in a group is for all its members to…well, be trustworthy.  Another way to facilitate trust is for team members get to know each other a bit before beginning work together, in order to discover common interests, similar (and different) styles, perspectives and goals.  This process may look different across groups:  Some may go to lunch together, some may do more formal, structured team-building activities and some may just talk for several minutes in their first group meeting.  Trust is also built when power struggles are avoided through shared ownership and control, successes are celebrated and through powerful shared experiences, such as ropes course participation.  For any over-sharers who may be reading, TMI is not a trust-building activity.

Effective Communication

As you remember from your undergraduate speech communication course, communication has two components: receiving and sending.  Most of us probably think of ourselves as good listeners but the research is startling:  “People only grasp about 50 percent of what they hear, even when they believe they are listening attentively” (Lucas, 2004, as cited in Komives, Wagner and Associates, 2009, p. 218). A more thorough summary of effective listening of this topic will have to wait for a later time, but listening can be improved by attending to content and emotion, paraphrasing and asking questions about what you’re hearing to check your understanding, and concentrating fully and patiently on what the other person is saying, without concurrently formulating your response or assuming you know what the speaker is going to say.

In terms of trust-building, the “sending” part of communication can be enhanced by using observations instead of evaluations – “You’ve been late three times this week” as opposed to “You’re never on time!” – and using requests instead of demands (Rosenberg, 1999 as cited in Komives, Wagner and Associates, 2009).

In summary, collaboration is a core value of this leadership model that can be built and strengthened in a variety of ways, starting with an individual’s self-knowledge and creating trust and effective communication.  Positive collaboration experiences feed the other “Cs” – Commitment, Congruence, and so on – as those “Cs” feed collaboration.

References
Covey, S.R. (1989). The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People. New York: Simon and Schuster.
Komives, S. R., Wagner, W. & Associates (2009). Leadership for a better world: Understanding the social change model of leadership development. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.

Wednesday, February 9, 2011

Leadership = Citizenship

This post continues our exploration of the Social Change Leadership Development Model.  For an overview of the model (and an explanation of what is meant by “social change”), please see the previous posts. 

As you can see in the figure below (source: http://www.leadershipstudy.net/ir-theoretical-model.html), the SCM is divided into three levels:  Individual, Group and Societal.  Today’s point on the journey is Citizenship.  Citizenship has many meanings and connotations but here is defined as working with others within one’s community, for the good of all.  A community is a group of people who have some defined trait or circumstance that binds them together, so you are likely a member of a variety of them:  The United States, your family, the University of Georgia, your field of study, your work group, and so on. This aspect of the SCM model is presented on the societal level but, as you can see by the community examples, citizenship also takes place on a limited micro level as well.  So, you may participate in citizenship in your community by taking part in a political rally with 200,000 other people in Washington DC to create some national reform or you may work with a group of three co-workers to create an awards and recognition program for your department or you may have a family meeting to discuss supporting mom’s sanity by picking up wet towels (or to discuss how to afford a lawyer for mom if the community fails and she finally snaps). 

The key trait linking citizenship to leadership is that they both involve working through others. Unless you’ve been cloned, you generally cannot lead a group consisting of just yourself, and citizenship is the same.  To be effective, the leader must be an engaged citizen of his or her community, whether that is at work, at home or elsewhere. 

Effective citizen leadership involves an understanding of several key concepts.

Social capital – Ever notice how you work better with those people you know a little better?  Most of us function better in systems in which we are not anonymous, in which we have some social capital.  Social capital is those activities, cultural norms, and other factors that lead community members to know and trust each other more, which in turn leads to greater effectiveness when that community comes together to act.   

Awareness of issues and community history – Knowing how the group has evolved (or devolved) over time and what issues are pertinent to them is critical to success.  Ever stepped on a figurative landmine because you didn’t know the history of the issue you were about to raise in a meeting?  If so, you know this process of getting in touch, and staying in touch, with the history of the group and its concerns is critical to effective leadership.

Empowerment – In any group, some feel empowered and others feel that they matter less.  Removing barriers to empowerment and actively involving all community members brings better ideas and more effective action to bear on any question or issue.

Empathy – Taking action and creating change virtually guarantee that opinions will clash.  This process can destroy a community or strengthen it, and one factor that supports the latter over the former is empathy, the ability to take the perspective of others.  Displaying empathy requires higher order cognitive development and is a key skill for all leaders.

Understanding of community development – An in-depth discussion of how communities develop is beyond the scope of this post but M. Scott Peck describes this well.  For social science types, this is similar to others’ description of group dynamics (e.g., Tuckman’s (1965) forming, storming, norming, performing).  Knowing that groups go through stages in their development – and how the leaders’ actions can push the group in one direction or other -- is critical to effective leadership.

Coalition-building – Many, if not most, problems beyond the scope of, “Where should we go for lunch?” are too large or complex for one group to solve.  In most cases, groups of diverse but like-minded individuals could benefit from creating coalitions to multiply their effectiveness.  Strategic and intelligent use of coalition-building magnifies leadership impact.

While citizenship may have connotations of voting or memorizing the Preamble to the Constitution in eighth grade civics class, it is a critical skill for leaders.

What communities are most important to you?

How have you worked within those communities to solve a problem or address an issue, whether it affected many people or few?

What could you do today to build more social capital, encourage empowerment and empathy of other community members, or build coalitions to increase effectiveness?



Wednesday, November 3, 2010

Leadership and Influence Summit

Short on time but interested in developing as a leader?  Here is a good resource:  The Leadership and Influence Summit.  It’s a free on-line conference where all the presenters provide their information via video in relatively short sessions (10 – 15 minutes).  The sponsors have increased the access time so that you can access these presentations until November 15.  The format allows you to select what sounds interesting and “leave” by moving on to something else if the session isn’t what you thought it would be.   You can also use the pause and rewind features of video to take great notes or interrupt the video to do something else for a minute.  I recommend Jim Kouzes’ (Leading in Turbulent Times) and Barry Posner’s (Leadership Truths) sessions as good places to start. 

Thursday, October 28, 2010

Leadership = Change




This post continues our exploration of the Social Change Leadership Development Model.  For an overview of the model (and an explanation of what is meant by “social change”), please see the previous post from September. 

As you can see in the figure below (source: http://www.leadershipstudy.net/ir-theoretical-model.html), the Social Change Leadership Development model is grounded in change.  The purpose of this piece is not to summarize the various theories and concepts of change.  There are many resources that do that and a few can be found below.  The purpose is to help you begin to think about your relationship to change as a foundation for understanding this model. 

The purpose of leadership is coping with or creating change, which distinguishes it from management (Kotter, 1990).  The purpose of management is to deal with complexity, to bring stability, order and efficiency to the work of the organization such that participants and stakeholders can do their work, have their expectations met, etc.  It involves tasks like planning, budgeting, organizing, staffing, problem solving, and so on.  Managers may create change, but it is normally incremental change in service of bringing order or stability.  For example, a school board may solve a problem of how to ensure continuity as board membership changes  by creating a resource book and systematic training that each new member participate in.  This is valuable, but is not change that will fundamentally alter the way the organization functions or set the direction for future progress.

Leadership is different from, but complementary to, management in that its purpose is to both cope with and create change (Kotter, 1990).  Leadership is concerned with setting a vision, motivating others, aligning systems and people and other important tasks that create and facilitate more comprehensive change.  Generally, the change facilitated by a leader is transformative, meaning that it doesn’t answer a question or solve a problem so much as alter which questions are asked or how problems are perceived or conceptualized.  To use the school board example above, transformative change would involve conceptualizing the impact the school system should have on its community, including which values the school system wants to exemplify, and then aligning the various resources and systems so that vision comes to reality.  Both leadership and management are necessary for any organization to function and both can be accomplished by the same person. 

It is important to understand how critical change is to leadership in order to understand subsequent posts in this series, in which we will explore how leaders create that change.  In other words, creating transformative change is the foundation on which the leadership house is built. Understanding these ideas – the change agent nature of leadership and how leadership is distinct from management -- is critical to your growth as a leader. 

How do you respond to change in your organization?

How do you create change in your organization?

What helps you to respond to or create change? What tools do you need?

How can we create environments where everyone can lead (create change) in some aspect of their work?

How has your perception of change grown or evolved over the course of your career?

Some change resources are:
Allen, K.E., & Cherrey, C. (2000).  Systematic leadership: Enriching the meaning of our work.  Washington, DC: University Press of America
Boyce, M. (2003).  Organizational learning is essential to achieving and sustaining change in higher education.  Innovative Higher Education, 28(2), 119-136.
Kotter, J. P. (1990). What leaders really do.  Harvard Business Review, 68(3), 103-11
Kotter, J. P. (1996). Leading change.  Boston: Harvard Business School Press.


(Image source: http://www.leadershipstudy.net/ir-theoretical-model.html)

Tuesday, September 28, 2010

Introduction to the Social Change Leadership Development Model

The Social Change Leadership Development Model (the Social Change Model or SCM) was originally developed at the Higher Education Research Institute (HERI) in the mid-1990s and continues to evolve.  This model reflects the more recent evolution in leadership development scholarship as a whole, which purports that leadership is less about the individual characteristics of positional leaders (transactional leadership) and more about the way leadership functions in a larger context of a group or organization to accomplish change (transformational leadership).

The SCM has several key assumptions (Komives and Wagner, 2009): 
1.        The point of leadership is producing change in a purposeful manner that benefits others.
2.       Collaboration is a hallmark of leadership.
3.       Leadership is more about process than the formal position or title of the leader.
4.       Leadership is value-laden.
5.       Everyone is a potential leader, regardless of their title or position within an organization.
6.       Service is a powerful tool for learning leadership.

The goal of the SCM is to create positive social change either on behalf of the individual or an institution/community or society.  “Positive social change” is conceived here as helping a group – such as a work group, an organization, or society – function more effectively and more responsibly.  This is where the value-laden aspect of the model emerges.  The model assumes that any group should act for the betterment of the group itself and/or others, whatever that may mean in any given context.  Due to the name of the model, it is easy to assume that it only applies to those who work in non-profit, activist, or similar settings but a close reading of the model reveals that it can apply anywhere.  Wagner (2009) summarizes by saying:
It is an approach to leadership that is collaborative rather than coercive, civil and respectful rather than defensive, open to different perspectives rather than controlling and single-minded, and clear and consistent about values rather than hypocritical.  While the primary mission of a group may not relate to social change, leaders in a variety of contexts, such as business, sports, theater groups, or a group classroom assignment, can benefit from these approaches to working with others (p. 33).

The SCM looks at leadership from three lenses:  the individual, the group/organization, and the community/society.  Seven fundamental values (the Seven Cs) are critical to the model (Komives and Wagner, 2009):
·         Consciousness of Self
·         Congruence
·         Commitment
·         Collaboration
·         Common Purpose
·         Controversy with Civility
·         Citizenship
·         Change

We will explore the Seven Cs through the lenses of individuals, groups and community over the coming months.  Your comments, questions and stories are a critical part of this exploration so I invite you to reflect and comment in the comments section below.

What do you think of this model and the philosophical context?  Can everyone be a leader in some aspect of their lives?

References
Komives, S. R. and Wagner, W. (2009). Preface.  In Komives, S. R., Wagner, W. and Associates (Eds.), Leadership for a Better World (pp. xi-xxv). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Wagner, W. (2009).  What is social change?.  In Komives, S. R., Wagner, W. and Associates (Eds.), Leadership for a Better World (pp. 7 - 42). San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Thursday, September 2, 2010

Listen Up, BP: What the Experts Say About Crisis Communication

Toyota and BP have recently been criticized not only for their problems but the way that they handled the problems publicly. These examples are business-related but public crises happen in all sizable organizations: The irregularities in the Georgia CRCT exams, the Atlanta Police Department raid that killed 92-year old Kathryn Johnston, and so on. The way an organization responds to crises is important but no less critical is how they communicate about their response.


To learn more about appropriate use of public relations, the AJC’s Henry Unger talked to three local PR experts. Read the entire article here. Here’s what the experts recommend for any organization handling a crisis:

1. Don’t wait. Take charge of informing the public immediately.

2. Plan your work and work your plan. All organizations should have an updated communications plan that has been vetted through crisis simulations. The uncertainty involved in these situations calls for more advance planning, not less.

3. Be clear. The entire organization should be clear on who the messenger is from the very beginning. The messenger should most likely be the CEO, mayor, superintendent or equivalent senior position.

4. Listen to your experts. Organizations should include their PR experts in their senior-level crisis team and listen to their advice.

5. Send the right message. It should always include these points:

• A clear description of what went wrong and expression of remorse.
• No minimization of the impact until everything is known about the situation.
• The organization’s immediate plans to make it right.
• The organization’s long-term plans to make it right, even as far as 5-10 years out.

Based on my experience handling smaller scale crises and observing others’ work with the big ones, I would add:

1. This advice is portable. While details may differ, these principles also apply to internal organizational communication about difficult predicaments and even, to a certain extent, to thorny one-on-one conversations.

2. It’s important that people know you get it. You should, if at all possible, apologize even if you didn’t directly cause the problem. At least say something compassionate that indicates you understand how the problem has affected people. They’re smart enough to figure out if a problem was caused by factors beyond your control and you can gently craft your words to help them connect the dots, without making excuses. The bottom line is that people need to know you understand the impact they’ve experienced.

3. No pseudo-apologies. If you say something along the lines of, “I’m sorry that people/the media, etc. misconstrued my comments,” it sounds condescending and infuriates people. Never do this -- ever -- whether it’s a personal disagreement or a public crisis. Apologize sincerely or don’t apologize at all, but don’t make fake apologies.

4. Transparency and courage pay dividends. Don’t dodge the media or treat them as enemies. Stand up, take the heat for what happened on your watch and try not to be defensive or secretive. Giving the appearance of covering something up or being less than forthcoming will only hurt you, even when you did nothing wrong.

What do you think of this advice? How would you or your organization use this information? What lessons have you learned about crisis communication in your experiences? What examples of good crisis communication have you seen?